- 1 this is what it means to say phoenix arizona setting analysis
- 1.1 “This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona” Analysis
- 1.2 The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven Summary and Analysis of "This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona"
- 1.3 Analysis of "This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona" by Sherman Alexie Essay
- 1.3.1 Related Documents: Analysis of "This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona" by Sherman Alexie Essay
- 1.3.2 Sherman Alexie and Victor’s Uncles Essay
- 1.3.3 Essay on Sherman Alexie One Book
- 1.3.4 what this song means to me Essay
- 1.3.5 Sherman Alexie and Indian Boys Body Essay
- 1.3.6 “Explain what it means to say religious language is: non cognitive and analogical” Essay examples
- 1.3.7 Essay about Sherman Alexie V. Frederick Douglass
- 1.3.8 Lisa Sherman Case Analysis Essay
- 1.3.9 Compare and Contrast- Sherman Alexie Essay
- 1.4 This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona Analysis
- 1.5 This is what it means to say phoenix, arizona Essay
- 1.6 This is what it means to say phoenix, arizona
this is what it means to say phoenix arizona setting analysis
“This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona” Analysis
Below is a free excerpt of "“This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona” Analysis" from Anti Essays, your source for free research papers, essays, and term paper examples.
Victor is noticeably unemotional over his father’s death. The two were obviously distant and yet Victor fulfills his duty as a son and picks up his father’s remains. One could argue that he went only for the truck and the few hundred dollars his father had in the bank, though he did feel some kind of love for his father. This is proven when Victor admits that although he does not want to go into the trailer where his father died, he must because “there might be something valuable in there… pictures and letters and stuff like that” (419). The mundane tone Alexie uses emphasizes the sad routines one follows after a loved one dies; life continues.
Alexie’s use of transitions between the present and memories of the past represent the memories that often pervade one’s mind when the experience a loss. Victor remembers a less complicated time from when he and Thomas were still friends. Then he remembers how their friendship crumbles as he sides with the rest of the boys who call Thomas weird and tease him. He does not remember his father. It is common to try to think of anyone or anything other than the dead. These.
The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven Summary and Analysis of "This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona"
Unlike many of the stories in the collection, this story is narrated in the third person. Victor’s father dies, and he is devastated although he has not seen him in a few years. Victor wants to go to Phoenix, where his father lived, to close his father’s savings account and pick up his ashes, but he doesn’t have enough money to do so. The tribal council normally puts money aside for situations like this, but they are low on cash and can only give him $100.
Thomas Builds-the-Fire offers to lend Victor the money on the condition that he accompany Victor to Phoenix. Victor is reluctant because Thomas is known for being eccentric - he tells the same stories over and over again, and sometimes talks nonsense. They were friends as young boys but haven’t been close for years. Victor remembers spending the Fourth of July with Thomas and listening to his stories. With no other option - and some guilt over his behavior towards his once friend - he decides to take up Thomas’s offer.
Victor remembers a time when he was 15 and beat Thomas badly while drunk. The other boys watched and did not intervene. Victor only stopped when Norma Many Horses, an older woman, intervened.
On the plane to Phoenix, Victor and Thomas sit next to Cathy, a former Olympic gymnast. Although Victor is initially embarrassed at Thomas’s attempts to converse with her, Cathy is friendly and they all enjoy talking to each other. When the plane lands, Victor apologizes for beating up Thomas. They arrive at Victor’s father’s trailer. Because Victor’s father’s body was not found for a week, the trailer reeks and it is difficult for Thomas and Victor to go in to sort through the man's things. Victor recalls how Thomas helped him when he got his foot stuck in a wasp's nest at age 12.
Thomas tells Victor a story about how when Thomas was 13, he had a dream that told him to walk to Spokane so he could have a vision. Victor’s father found Thomas there, and drove him back to the reservation on the condition that Thomas promise to watch out for Victor over the years. Victor remembers a time Thomas jumped off a roof because he believed he could fly, and did seem to fly for a second before falling to the ground.
After collecting Victor’s father’s ashes, money, and car, Victor and Thomas drive back to Spokane. As they pass through Nevada, they note that there is no plant or animal life. They finally see a jackrabbit, and Thomas accidentally runs it down with the car. When they arrive back in Spokane, Victor and Thomas acknowledge that the trip probably won’t bring them closer together. However, Victor gives Thomas a portion of his father’s ashes. Thomas promises to scatter them at the waterfall in Spokane, and asks Victor one favor - to listen to one of his stories, just once.
“This Is What It Means. ” has an episodic, non-chronological structure. This means that the story is related as a series of anecdotes from different points in Victor’s life. Although the main plotline of Victor and Thomas traveling to Phoenix is related chronologically, Victor’s many flashbacks to his relationship with Thomas are not. By presenting a single narrative interspersed with flashbacks, Alexie mimics memory - triggered by free association rather than strict chronology.
Alexie draws on his poetry background throughout the story, especially in Victor’s conversation with the tribal council. The recurrence of the phrase “now Victor” (60) adds a repetitive rhythm to the discussion and reflects Victor’s frustration with the bureaucracy. In the scene in the Nevada desert, Alexie also uses personification, another technique often associated with poetry. Victor notices that the air is imbued with “emptiness and loneliness” (72). By giving the desert air human characteristics, Alexie emphasizes the differences between the places that Thomas and Victor visit on their journey and the reservation back home. For all its problems (which the other stories in the collection describe and critique in great detail), the reservation is still a place where life can grow and flourish.
Although “This Is What It Means. ” focuses on Victor’s point of view, it can also be read as a character sketch of Thomas Builds-the-Fire. Thomas appears in many stories in the collection, but this one gives a detailed explanation of why Victor remains friends with Thomas (and harbors a sense of grudging respect toward him) despite the fact that he dislikes him and his stories. However, Thomas remains something of a mysterious figure. Although most of the collection’s main characters - including Victor, Junior Polatkin, and Norma Many Horses – change and develop over the course of the stories in which they appear, Thomas Builds-the-Fire remains largely unaffected by his experiences. In the flashbacks to Victor and Thomas’s shared adolescence, Thomas demonstrates the same tolerance, love of storytelling, and otherworldly qualities that he has as an adult, unlike Victor, who has become a great deal more compassionate and responsible since he bullied Thomas as a teenager.
Analysis of "This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona" by Sherman Alexie Essay
Related Documents: Analysis of "This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona" by Sherman Alexie Essay
Sherman Alexie and Victor’s Uncles Essay
his parents, who are both passed out. The next morning, the hurricane is gone and life goes on as before. Analysis This story introduces Victor, a character who appears in many stories in the collection. He grows from child to adult on the reservation, and his story is similar to Alexie’s in that he is one of the few people on the reservation to leave and attend college. Like Alexie, Victor will also have a brief, problematic relationship with alcohol before becoming sober as a young adult…
Words 597 - Pages 3
Essay on Sherman Alexie One Book
Discussion Professor Lessen September 29, 2014 The Spokane Indians originate from the Spokane River in Eastern Washington. This tribe has existed since the 1300’s and is still an active tribe on the Spokane reservation. Robert H Ruby, a professor the course "Indians of the Pacific Northwest", wrote a book “The Spokane Indians Children of the Sun” which was published in 1&70; this book contains detailed information on The Spokane Indian Tribe discovered during his time spent in Spokane, WA when studying…
Words 538 - Pages 3
Monroe, La., later lived in Bastrop, Louisiana for 10 years; now I moved back to my hometown. I am married but separated. I have two girls, one is 15 and the oldest is 18. I am attending University of Phoenix to achieve my career in Criminal Justice. This is my first day at University of Phoenix. Experience C.N.A. since 2000; passionate about helping and has a good interpersonal skills and always welcome a challenge. Excellent Organizational Skills, Computer Proficiency, Data Entry, Word Perfect…
Words 452 - Pages 2
“This is Just to Say,” William Carlos Williams We love this poem for its sheer deliciousness. It reads like a piece of the most beautifully written found poetry — a note taped to the icebox door. Succinct, simple, and yet juicy, the limited lines profess a narrative far beyond what actually exists on the page. http://flavorwire.com/217118/10-poems-everyone-needs-to-read I have eaten the plums that were in the icebox and which you were probably saving for breakfast Forgive me they were delicious…
Words 531 - Pages 3
what this song means to me Essay
ELIJAH INTERIANO Mrs. Martinez E/LA 7 2 September, 2013 SAY WHAT? After analyzing the lyrics, I can infer the song is about, one spreading the word about god and teaching other people about GOD. Second is Lecrae (the singer) singing about how GOD can change you and your life like how GOD changed his life. Last of all is Lecrae doesn’t understand why GOD is doing these amazing things to change his life…
Words 485 - Pages 2
Sherman Alexie and Indian Boys Body Essay
Shame can lead to confrontations, which can lead to violence. In Sherman Alexie’s Flight the main character Zits has been in and out of twenty foster homes. In a later scene Zits spirit walks into a little Indian boy’s body at the Little battle of bighorn where he discovers he has a father and a family. Zits is happy for the first time in his life. Alexie shows how kids need a family to love and to care about. Through Zits Alexie shows how kids who grow up without parents struggle to have long lasting…
Words 379 - Pages 2
“Explain what it means to say religious language is: non cognitive and analogical” Essay examples
analogical’. Non-cognitive language is language that cannot be empirically verified. For example, “obey God to be sure of heaven.” Firstly the statement requires verification that there is a God and also that there is another place after death. None of this can be totally verified until after death. Religious statements are really moral statements, they express an attitude and so have an emotive meaning, they are designed to shape people's feelings and behaviour and are meaningful in having such results…
Words 1103 - Pages 5
Essay about Sherman Alexie V. Frederick Douglass
Compare and Contrast Essay Frederick Douglass V. Sherman Alexie As a young child, we are given certain opportunities and guidance to expand our knowledge right off the bat when it comes to reading and writing. Going to school to get an education is what every parent aspires their child to do. Parents want the best for their children, to be accepted and to learn to their fullest extent just like every other child their age. However, there are many children and families who are not as privileged…
Words 1266 - Pages 6
Lisa Sherman Case Analysis Essay
Lisa Sherman Case Analysis: October 2010 Summary: Lisa Sherman worked for Verizon for many years. While there she never revealed her sexual orientation .Then one fated day, there was a diversification workshop with her fellow managers. The outcome of this was that her coworkers were bigoted towards homosexuality. Lisa Sherman had a tough decision to make, whether to stay or to leave. The following analysis shows a suggested solution. Lisa Sherman Case Analysis: Lisa Sherman spent many…
Words 1122 - Pages 5
Compare and Contrast- Sherman Alexie Essay
Compare and Contrast In Sherman Alexie’s The Absolutely True Diary of a Part-Time Indian, Junior is a young American Indian that is shy and has low self-esteem, and has a few issues physically and his surroundings. He has a best friend named Rowdy. Rowdy is rude and has no emotion to any situation. What many people at the reservation don’t know is that Rowdy and Junior have real problems at home with their parents. The differences between Rowdy and Junior are the family and the personalities.…
Words 885 - Pages 4
* Test names and other trademarks are the property of the respective trademark holders.
None of the trademark holders are affiliated with this website.
All content of site and tests copyright © 2018 Study Mode, LLC.
This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona Analysis
(Comprehensive Guide to Short Stories, Critical Edition)
The seventh story within Alexie’s short-story collection The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fistfight in Heaven (1993), “This is What it Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona” continues the story of Victor, an alienated young Indian man. Dialogue is used extensively. Alexie wrote the screenplay for the film Smoke Signals (1999) based on this short story.
Told in the third person, mainly through the consciousness of Victor, the tone is bleak, even cynical at times, with small details carrying great weight. Though this story is more psychological than political or social, references to the BIA, Thomas Builds-the-Fire’s HUD (U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development) house, poverty, alcohol, and the reservation underscore the tragic history of the Native Americans’ interactions with the U.S. government and their psychological consequences.
In the first two sentences of the story the reader learns that Victor has just lost his job, that his father has died of a heart attack, and that soon Victor will be in great pain. However, this tone is offset by the character of Thomas Builds-the-Fire, who brings into the story both hope and comic relief. Although the reservation is presented as a place where history has produced poverty, alcoholism, and disillusionment, Thomas, himself a product of the reservation, seems to have transcended this. Though he is ignored, his Indian name links him with everything Indian and traditional. Like Norma Many Horses, who is described as a “warrior,” Thomas is, in his own way, “powerful.” Therefore, his connection with Victor produces the seeds for Victor’s transformation. In the same way that Thomas Builds-the-Fire’s name is meaningful, Victor’s name indicates that he will be victorious.
By using a central story told within a number of smaller stories, Alexie weaves a tapestry from the threads of the past, which allows Victor, through his own memories and his connection with Thomas, to rise above his circumstances. Thomas envisions Victor’s father rising like a salmon when he throws his ashes over the water of Spokane Falls. However, Alexie implies that it is Victor who will rise from the ashes, a young man who will be reborn, like the phoenix, from the flames of his own suffering and pain—flames kindled by his journey with Thomas Builds-the-Fire.
This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona Homework Help Questions
The thought "Desperate times call for desperate measures" is from a proverb that has no attribution to a specific author or speaker. This philosophical proverb, which is considered an English.
Sherman Alexie grew up on an Indian Reservation in Washington State. His story “This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona” comes from his experiences on the reservations. Unfortunately.
Victor Joseph is the main character in "This is What it Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona" by Native American author Sherman Alexie. The story revolves around a pivotal rite of passage, the death of a.
Thomas closed his eyes and this story came to him: "We are all given one thing by which our lives are measured, one determination. Mine are the stories which can change or not change the world. It.
The story of "This Is What It Means to Say Phoenix, Arizona" says that when Victor and Thomas Builds-the-Fire were seven-years-old, Thomas told the story about Victor's father watching TV all night.
This is what it means to say phoenix, arizona Essay
This is what it means to say phoenix, arizona
The setting of the airplane adds meaning and understanding to the story. During the flight, we get to see the first person-to-person interaction Thomas Builds-the-Fire has with someone other than Victor. This interaction seals the lid on any conjectures we had about Thomas’s social skills, maturity level and understanding of his Indian ancestry.
Thomas’s social skills and maturity are shown greatly when he begins to talk to the beautiful gymnast. Thomas presents himself in a confident manner and isn’t shy or afraid. He even starts to throw in a few jokes into the conversation, which makes them chuckle. His maturity level is strongly presented when he tries to mock the gymnast and pull his leg above his head, which of course he failed in doing. Thomas shows his social skills and maturity level during this plane trip help to explain how he is treated on the reservation. The Indians on the reservation threat him as an outside because of his off the wall actions. His immaturity and his story telling seem to annoy other Indians. These people on the reservation have made him an outcast. Thomas’s actions on the plane trip exemplify why they do.
Thomas also seems to have knowledge of his heritage background. His pun on the plane about the Indians being shunned proves this. This seems to be important by the end of the story. At the end, Thomas decides to toss his ashes of Victor’s dad in the river, so that Victor’s dad will, “rise like a salmon…and find his way home.” This is an old Indian way. Indians like to use metaphors using animals and believe in reincarnation. This saying bring an ending to the story and a nice conclusion of the journey the to had took. If one wouldn’t recognize that Thomas does have knowledge of his Indian ancestry, they may think he is just weird. But, knowing his knowledge, we can begin to understand why he does the things he does.
The setting and action on the plane trip are important to the understanding of the story and its plot because it brings insight to the reader we hadn’t known or understood before about the characters.
University/College: University of Arkansas System
Type of paper: Thesis/Dissertation Chapter
Date: 3 July 2016
Let us write you a custom essay sample on This is what it means to say phoenix, arizona